How Does Impermanent Loss Work With a Stablecoin? ETH/USDC and Stablecoin-Only Pools Explained

On this page
I have been a liquidity provider on a DeFi lending platform for the past month, and this is the first time I have a stablecoin within my trading pair. Would this increase my risk of impermanent loss, or will my stablecoin balance out the volatile crypto coin (Eth)?
The short answer
Putting a stablecoin in your pair does not shield you from impermanent loss. In an ETH/USDC pool, the stablecoin stays at $1, so the loss is driven entirely by how far ETH’s price moves from where you deposited, up or down. A 2x move in ETH costs about 5.7% compared with just holding the two tokens, before fees.
Pools made of two stablecoins are different: while both keep their peg, impermanent loss is close to zero. The risk there is a depeg. If one coin loses its peg, traders dump it into the pool, and liquidity providers end up holding mostly the broken coin.
Why impermanent loss happens
An automated market maker pool keeps its price in line with the market through arbitrage. When ETH rises, arbitrageurs buy the cheap ETH from the pool until its price matches other markets, so the pool, and your share of it, ends up holding less ETH and more USDC. When ETH falls, the opposite happens: you end up with more ETH and less USDC.
Either way, you sold some of the asset that went up and bought some of the asset that went down. Compared with simply holding your original tokens, that leaves you with less value. That shortfall is impermanent loss. It’s called “impermanent” because it disappears if prices return to where you entered, but it becomes real the moment you withdraw. Our explainers on what impermanent loss means and how it works in DeFi cover the basics.
Worked example: an ETH/USDC pool
You deposit 1 ETH and 3,000 USDC ($6,000 in total, with ETH at $3,000) into a standard 50/50 constant-product pool. Ignoring fees:
| ETH price later | Value if you’d just held | Value in the pool | Impermanent loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| $3,000 (no change) | $6,000 | $6,000 | 0% |
| $6,000 (2x) | $9,000 | about $8,485 (0.707 ETH + 4,243 USDC) | about 5.7% |
| $1,500 (0.5x) | $4,500 | about $4,243 (1.414 ETH + 2,121 USDC) | about 5.7% |
The loss is the same for a doubling and a halving. It comes from the standard formula in Uniswap’s documentation, IL = 2 × √r ÷ (1 + r) − 1, where r is the price ratio between entry and exit:
| Price change of the volatile token | Impermanent loss vs. holding |
|---|---|
| 1.25x or 0.8x | about 0.6% |
| 1.5x or 0.67x | about 2.0% |
| 2x or 0.5x | about 5.7% |
| 3x or 0.33x | about 13.4% |
| 4x or 0.25x | about 20.0% |
So to answer the original question: the stablecoin doesn’t “balance out” ETH’s volatility. It’s the reference point the loss is measured against. In dollar terms you still gain when ETH rises (from $6,000 to about $8,485 above), just less than if you’d held. Compared with a pair of two assets that tend to move together, ETH/USDC can actually have more impermanent loss, because USDC never moves with ETH.
Concentrated liquidity makes it bigger
On Uniswap v3 and v4, PancakeSwap v3 and similar DEXs, you can put your liquidity in a narrow price range. That earns more fees per dollar while the price stays in range, but it magnifies impermanent loss for the same price move. If ETH moves outside your range, your position becomes 100% of one token: all USDC if ETH rose above the range, all ETH if it fell below. It stops earning fees until the price comes back or you reposition. Concentrated ETH/USDC positions behave much more like an active trading strategy than a passive deposit.
Stablecoin-only pools: near zero, until a depeg
Pools of two or more coins meant to be worth $1, such as USDC/USDT, have minimal impermanent loss because the price ratio barely moves. Curve’s stableswap pools are built for this: they concentrate liquidity around a 1:1 price, so swaps are cheap and the pool can drift quite far from equal balances while still working.
The weak spot is a depeg. If one coin starts trading below $1 elsewhere, arbitrageurs sell it into the pool and take the healthy coins out. Curve’s risk disclosure says that in this situation LPs effectively hold almost all their liquidity in the depegged token, and if it never regains its peg, they take losses in proportion to the severity of the depeg.
An illustrative case: you deposit 1,000 USDC and 1,000 USDT, then USDC falls to $0.88.
- If you’d just held, you’d have about $1,880.
- In a stableswap pool that ends up almost entirely USDC, you’d hold roughly 2,000 USDC worth about $1,760, a loss of around 6% versus holding.
- In a simple constant-product pool, impermanent loss for a 12% price gap would be only about 0.2%, but such pools are rarely used for stablecoins because they offer traders far worse prices.
The stableswap design that makes stablecoin pools efficient is the same thing that makes them take on so much of a failing coin.
Two real depegs, two different outcomes
- USDC, March 2023. After Circle disclosed reserves held at the failed Silicon Valley Bank, traders swapped USDC and DAI for USDT in Curve’s large 3pool. The pool’s on-chain balances show USDT falling below 2% of the pool on March 11, 2023, with a low of roughly 1.3% that morning (UTC). USDC recovered its peg within days once US regulators backstopped the bank’s depositors, and by late March the pool had moved back to roughly 36% USDC, 37% DAI and 27% USDT, so LPs who stayed in largely saw the imbalance unwind. The loss really was impermanent.
- TerraUSD (UST), May 2022. UST was an algorithmic stablecoin. When it collapsed, pools pairing it with other stablecoins filled up with UST, and it never recovered. For LPs in those pools, the loss was permanent.
The type of stablecoin matters. Our guide to the safest stablecoins explains how to judge backing, redemption and depeg history.
Do fees make up for it?
LPs earn a share of trading fees, which can offset impermanent loss; see how liquidity pool fees work. The balance depends on volume and volatility. Choppy, high-volume markets favor LPs, because prices swing back and forth while fees pile up. Strong one-way trends favor holding. For stablecoin pools, fees are low and steady, so a single depeg can wipe out years of fee income.
Researchers also measure a related cost called loss-versus-rebalancing (LVR): because pool prices update only when arbitrageurs trade against them, LPs keep selling to better-informed traders at slightly stale prices. Unlike impermanent loss, this cost doesn’t reverse if the price comes back, and it is one reason a volatile/stablecoin pool can underperform even when fees look healthy.
Risks to weigh before providing liquidity
- Divergence risk in volatile/stablecoin pairs: large moves in either direction cost you relative to holding.
- Depeg risk in stablecoin pools: you can end up holding mostly the weakest coin.
- Range risk in concentrated liquidity: out-of-range positions earn nothing and hold one asset.
- Smart-contract and incentive risk: pools can be exploited, and reward tokens that boost advertised yields can fall in value.
- Exit timing: impermanent loss becomes permanent when you withdraw, and withdrawing during a depeg locks in the worst of it.
Ways to manage these, from choosing correlated pairs to hedging, are covered in how to avoid impermanent loss and ways to hedge impermanent loss. If you want stablecoin yield without LP exposure, compare the options in whether stablecoin yield farming is a good investment, or start from the stablecoins guide.
Frequently asked questions
Do stablecoin pairs have impermanent loss?
A pair of two stablecoins has very little while both hold their peg. A pair of a stablecoin and a volatile token, such as ETH/USDC, has the same impermanent loss as any 50/50 pool, driven by the volatile token's price moves.
Is ETH/USDC riskier than ETH/BTC for impermanent loss?
Impermanent loss depends on how much the two assets move relative to each other. ETH and BTC often move together, so their ratio can change less than ETH's dollar price does, which would mean less impermanent loss than ETH/USDC. That correlation isn't guaranteed.
What happens to a Curve stablecoin pool if a stablecoin depegs?
Traders sell the depegged coin into the pool and take out the healthy ones, so LPs end up holding mostly the depegged coin. Curve's own risk disclosure says LPs then hold almost all their liquidity in that token, and if it never recovers the loss becomes permanent.
Can trading fees cover impermanent loss?
Sometimes. Fees accumulate with volume, while impermanent loss grows with price divergence. In calm, high-volume markets fees can exceed it; in sharp one-directional moves they often don't.
How do I avoid impermanent loss with stablecoins?
You can't remove it entirely as an LP. You can reduce it by choosing pairs that move together, using stablecoins with robust backing, using wider ranges, or lending stablecoins instead of providing liquidity.
Sources
- Uniswap developer docs: Understanding returns (impermanent loss formula)
- Uniswap developer docs: Concentrated liquidity
- Curve docs: Liquidity pools risk disclaimer (permanent loss of a peg)
- Curve docs: Stableswap and Cryptoswap pools
- Etherscan: Curve 3pool contract (balances() read at archive blocks, March 10-12, 2023)
- CoinDesk: Circle's USDC remains dominant in DeFi as pressure eases (March 30, 2023)
Educational content, not financial advice. DeFi carries risk, including total loss of funds.