Is DAI a Safe Stablecoin in 2026? DAI, USDS and Sky's Risks Explained

On this page
Hi, I'm looking to buy stablecoins and I was wondering whether DAI would be a good choice?
The short answer
DAI is one of the longest-running and better-tested stablecoins in DeFi, but it is not “safe” in the sense of a guaranteed $1. It has held close to its peg for most of its life since 2017, and it is backed by more collateral than the DAI in circulation. It has also broken its peg in a crisis: in March 2023, when USDC wobbled after Silicon Valley Bank failed, DAI fell with it to around $0.88–$0.90 before recovering within days.
Two other things have changed since this question was first asked. MakerDAO is now called Sky, and Sky’s flagship stablecoin is now USDS, an upgraded version of DAI. DAI still exists and works, and you can swap between them 1:1 at any time. So in 2026, asking whether DAI is safe really means asking whether Sky’s system is safe, because both coins share the same backing.
This page explains how that system works and what can go wrong. It is not a recommendation to buy or hold DAI or USDS.
How DAI works
DAI is a crypto-collateralized stablecoin, originally created by the Maker Protocol:
- Borrowers lock collateral such as ETH in a vault and mint DAI against it. They must keep more collateral than the DAI they owe, the principle of over-collateralization.
- If the collateral falls too far, the vault is liquidated: the collateral is sold to repay the debt.
- The protocol also holds stable assets. A Peg Stability Module lets users swap USDC and DAI/USDS 1:1, which keeps the price close to $1 but means part of the backing is USDC.
- Real-world assets. Over time Maker, and now Sky, has put a large share of reserves into tokenized short-term Treasuries and other real-world assets, mostly through Sky’s allocator units (“Stars”) such as Spark and Grove.
For the full mechanics, see how DAI tokens work and the history of MakerDAO.
Is DAI an algorithmic stablecoin like UST?
No. The collapse of TerraUSD in 2022 led many people to lump DAI in with “algorithmic” coins, but the designs are fundamentally different. UST was backed mainly by its own sister token, LUNA, so a loss of confidence fed on itself. DAI is backed by external assets worth more than the DAI issued, and positions are liquidated before they become under-collateralized. See why algorithmic stablecoins are so risky.
DAI vs USDS: what changed with Sky
In 2024, MakerDAO rebranded as Sky and launched USDS and a new governance token, SKY. As of November 2026:
| DAI | USDS | |
|---|---|---|
| Issuer | Sky (formerly MakerDAO) | Sky |
| Backing | Shared with USDS | Shared with DAI |
| Supply (approx., Nov 2026) | ~$4.6B | ~$5.2B |
| Savings rate (approx., Nov 2026) | DAI Savings Rate, ~1.25% (sDAI) | Sky Savings Rate, ~3.8% (sUSDS) |
| Contract | Original DAI contract, no freeze function | Upgradeable; launched with no active freeze function |
| Conversion | 1:1 to USDS, no fee | 1:1 to DAI, no fee |
| Where it lives | Mostly Ethereum, some Polygon and others | Mostly Ethereum, small amounts on Solana, Base and other chains |
Supply figures come from DefiLlama and savings rates from DefiLlama’s yields data; both change, so check live figures.
Key points about the switch:
- Conversion is free and two-way. Sky’s developer docs state the DAI-USDS converter charges no fees and that fees cannot be enabled on this route in the future. You pay only network gas.
- The savings rates differ. Sky governance sets them separately, and in late 2026 the USDS rate is far higher than the DAI rate. Any rate can change; see how much interest you can earn with DAI.
- The freeze debate. When USDS was announced in August 2024, co-founder Rune Christensen said it would launch with no active freeze function but with an upgrade ability, drawing criticism from users who valued DAI’s censorship resistance. DAI itself is not affected.
- MKR became SKY. MKR converts to SKY at a fixed 1:24,000 ratio, one way only, minus a “delayed upgrade penalty” for late converters. The penalty started at 1% in September 2025 and has been raised in steps since; the converter contract showed 5% in mid-November 2026.
Track record under stress
| Event | What happened to DAI |
|---|---|
| “Black Thursday”, March 2020 | ETH crashed and network congestion let some liquidation auctions clear at zero bids. Several million dollars of DAI was left under-collateralized (estimates vary), and Maker minted and sold new MKR to cover the shortfall. The auction system was redesigned afterwards. |
| TerraUSD collapse, May 2022 | DAI held its peg while UST failed. |
| USDC depeg, March 2023 | Because much of DAI’s backing was USDC, DAI followed USDC down to around $0.88–$0.90 when Circle disclosed $3.3B stuck at Silicon Valley Bank, then recovered after US authorities backstopped SVB deposits. |
The lesson from 2023 is that DAI is only as stable as its largest collateral. Holding a “decentralized” stablecoin does not remove exposure to banks if the reserves include a bank-dependent coin. Some readers also see small price swings on DAI; see why DAI can look volatile.
What the ratings say
In August 2025, S&P Global gave Sky Protocol a B- issuer credit rating, the first rating it assigned to a DeFi protocol, covering USDS, DAI and the sUSDS and sDAI savings tokens. It also assessed USDS’s ability to hold its peg at 4 (constrained) on its 1-to-5 stablecoin stability scale. S&P’s concerns included:

- Weak capitalization: a risk-adjusted capital ratio of 0.4%, leaving a thin buffer against credit losses.
- Centralized governance: low voter turnout, with co-founder Rune Christensen holding almost 9% of governance tokens.
- Depositor concentration and regulatory uncertainty.
S&P also noted minimal credit losses since 2020. Its separate stability assessment of USDS/DAI was still 4 (constrained), dated December 8, 2025, in the list S&P published in August 2026. On October 1, 2026, S&P affirmed the B- rating with a stable outlook, according to ChainCatcher’s report, noting that combined USDS and DAI supply had grown to about $9.5 billion while Sky’s loss-absorbing reserves were about $92 million against a $150 million target, and that USDC and tokenized government money market funds now backed about half of circulating USDS and DAI. Days later, on October 7, 2026, Moody’s assigned Sky a B3 issuer rating with a stable outlook, its first rating of a stablecoin protocol. Both ratings sit well below investment grade. A rating is an opinion, not a guarantee, but it is a useful outside view. For comparison, S&P’s August 2026 list put USDC at 2 (strong) and USDT at 5 (weak); see which stablecoin is safest.
The risks of holding DAI or USDS
- Collateral risk. A sharp crash in crypto collateral or losses on real-world assets could leave the system short. Real-world assets also depend on off-chain custodians and legal agreements that you cannot verify on-chain.
- USDC dependence. USDC in the Peg Stability Module ties DAI and USDS to Circle and its banks, as March 2023 showed.
- Smart-contract risk. Sky’s contracts are heavily audited and long-running, but bugs in them, in the allocators, or in apps you use DAI in can still cause losses. See how safe the DAI Maker protocol is.
- Governance risk. Token holders can change rates, collateral rules and, for USDS, contract code. Voting power is concentrated.
- Thin capital buffer. As S&P highlighted, the surplus available to absorb losses is small relative to the system’s size.
- No regulation or insurance. DAI and USDS are not issued under the GENIUS Act or EU MiCA, and they are not bank deposits.
- Platform risk. DAI held on an exchange or deposited in a lending app also carries that platform’s risk.
DAI compared with other stablecoins
| DAI / USDS | USDC | USDT | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Crypto- and RWA-collateralized | Fiat-backed | Fiat-backed |
| Issuer | Decentralized protocol (Sky) | Circle | Tether |
| Freeze function | No (DAI); upgradeable (USDS) | Yes | Yes |
| Redemption | Via the protocol and markets | 1:1 for Circle Mint business customers | 1:1 for verified customers, $100,000 minimum |
| S&P stability assessment | 4 (constrained, USDS) | 2 (strong) | 5 (weak) |
For a deeper one-on-one, read USDC vs DAI. If you are looking at DAI to earn interest, can you make money from stablecoins? covers the options and risks.
Bottom line
DAI has a long record and a transparent, over-collateralized design, which is why many DeFi users treat it as one of the sturdier stablecoins. It is not a savings account with deposit protection: it relies on collateral values, USDC, real-world-asset custodians, smart contracts and a concentrated governance system. If you hold it, understand that DAI and USDS share one balance sheet, watch how that backing changes, and consider spreading stablecoin holdings across different issuers and designs.
Frequently asked questions
Is DAI backed by real dollars?
Not directly. DAI is created when users lock collateral worth more than the DAI they borrow, and the system also holds USDC and tokenized real-world assets such as short-term Treasuries. There is no company that redeems DAI for dollars in a bank account.
Should I switch from DAI to USDS?
That depends on what you need. USDS is where Sky's new features and its higher savings rate are, while DAI has the longer track record, is more widely integrated in older DeFi apps and has no upgradeable contract. You can convert either way 1:1 with no conversion fee, paying only gas.
Is DAI algorithmic?
Not in the way TerraUSD was. TerraUSD was backed mainly by its own sister token; DAI is over-collateralized by external assets and can be liquidated if collateral falls in value. Smart contracts and incentives, not a company, manage the peg.
Can DAI be frozen?
DAI's token contract has no freeze function. USDS launched without an active freeze function, but its contract is upgradeable, so Sky governance could add one later. Collateral like USDC held by the protocol can itself be frozen by its issuer.
How much interest does DAI earn?
Only if you deposit it. As of mid-November 2026, DefiLlama shows the DAI Savings Rate (sDAI) at about 1.25% and the Sky Savings Rate on USDS (sUSDS) at about 3.8%. Both are set by Sky governance and change.
Is DAI regulated?
No. DAI and USDS are issued by a decentralized protocol, not a licensed payment-stablecoin issuer, so they are not covered by frameworks like the US GENIUS Act or EU MiCA authorization, and there is no deposit insurance.
Sources
- Sky developer docs: USDS and the DAI-USDS converter
- Sky developer docs: MKR to SKY upgrade for token holders
- Cointelegraph: S&P Global gives Sky Protocol a B- rating (Aug 2025)
- Cointelegraph: Sky's USDS stablecoin criticized over freeze function (Aug 2024)
- The Block: USDC and DAI remain at about $0.90 after Circle discloses SVB exposure (March 2023)
- S&P Global Ratings: More than half of Stablecoin Stability Assessments are adequate or above (Aug 4, 2026)
- Etherscan: MkrSky converter contract (MKR_SKY in Sky's chainlog; fee() = 5% on Nov 16, 2026)
- ChainCatcher: S&P affirms Sky Protocol at B- (Oct 2026)
- The Block: Moody's gives Sky Protocol a B3 rating (Oct 2026)
- Glassnode: What really happened to MakerDAO (Black Thursday, 2020)
- DefiLlama: Stablecoins by market cap (DAI and USDS supply)
- DefiLlama: Yields (sDAI and sUSDS savings rates)
Educational content, not financial advice. DeFi carries risk, including total loss of funds.